Indonesia’s Energy Transition: Ambitious Goals Amidst Coal Reliance Challenges

Indonesia stands at a critical juncture in its energy transition journey, grappling with the stark reality of its carbon emissions and the ambitious commitments laid out by President Prabowo Subianto. In 2022, the Southeast Asian nation released approximately 650 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, positioning itself as the world’s seventh-largest carbon emitter. As it aims to retire coal power plants within 15 years while ramping up renewable energy capacity to over 75 gigawatts by 2040, the challenges ahead are monumental.

Experts are sounding alarms about the feasibility of these targets, particularly in a country where coal accounts for a staggering 66% of electricity generation. Indonesia’s reliance on coal isn’t just a matter of energy; it’s deeply intertwined with its economic fabric, especially in the nickel processing sector, which is crucial for the global supply chain of stainless steel and electric vehicles. The stakes are high, and the path to net zero emissions by 2050—a goal set a decade earlier than the previous administration—requires not just ambition but a complete overhaul of existing policies.

To achieve this ambitious roadmap, Indonesia must first confront its systemic issues. Fabby Tumiwa, from the Institute for Essential Services Reform, has highlighted the need for comprehensive reforms. These include dismantling policies that favor fossil fuels and prioritizing the development of clean energy infrastructure. The International Energy Agency has echoed this sentiment, emphasizing that Indonesia must phase out fossil fuel subsidies and rethink its approach to energy pricing to make renewables more competitive.

Currently, the playing field is heavily skewed in favor of coal. The government imposes a price ceiling on coal for power plants, making it the go-to choice for energy generation. Meanwhile, renewable energy producers are shackled by regulations that require them to sell their power to the state utility at prices that deter investment. Tumiwa’s call for increased attractiveness of renewable investments underscores the urgency of this situation.

The numbers paint a grim picture. Indonesia needs to invest at least $1.2 trillion in clean energy and infrastructure by 2050, alongside $28 billion for the early retirement of coal plants. Yet, in 2023, the renewable energy sector attracted only $1.5 billion in investments. To meet Prabowo’s goals, the country would need to build 8 gigawatts of renewable energy capacity annually, while simultaneously retiring 3 gigawatts of coal each year until 2040. However, between 2018 and 2023, Indonesia added a mere 3.3 gigawatts of renewable power.

The challenge is further compounded by the geographical diversity of Indonesia, which consists of thousands of islands. The untapped potential for geothermal, wind, hydro, and solar energy often lies in remote areas, far from Java, where the majority of the population resides. This geographical hurdle necessitates significant investments in transmission lines and energy storage solutions to ensure a reliable clean power supply.

As Indonesia moves forward, external financing remains a pressing concern. A $22 billion support package from developed nations, including the US and Japan, was agreed upon in 2022 to aid Indonesia’s transition from coal. However, the disbursement of these funds has been painfully slow, hampering the momentum needed for change.

The road ahead is fraught with challenges. Indonesia’s track record on previous energy transition commitments raises eyebrows, and analysts warn that Prabowo’s ambitious goals could face significant implementation hurdles. As the world watches, Indonesia must navigate the delicate balance between economic growth and environmental responsibility, all while addressing its energy security. The coming years will be pivotal in determining whether Indonesia can transform its energy landscape or remain mired in its coal-dependent past.

Scroll to Top
×